• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Social Velocity

Creating more strategic, financially savvy, and confident nonprofit leaders and organizations.

  • Consulting
    • Financial Model Assessment
    • Strategic Advising
    • Strategic Planning
  • Book
  • Clients
  • Speaking
  • Blog
  • About
    • Nell Edington’s Bio
    • Media
  • Connect
  • Tools
Home » Board of Directors » Fundraising’s Shiny Object Syndrome

September 2, 2014 By Nell Edgington 6 Comments

Fundraising’s Shiny Object Syndrome

FacebookTweetLinkedIn

I have to be honest. I am so sick of hearing about the ice bucket challenge that I am loathe to write about it. But I wonder if many in the nonprofit and philanthropic sector are falling victim, yet again, to shiny object syndrome, so I feel compelled to say something.

To me the ice bucket challenge is yet another example of what happens so often in the world of fundraising. Nonprofit board members and staff hate fundraising, so they desperately search for a magic bullet to make it all go away.

Sometimes that magic bullet is “an endowment,” sometimes its “earned income,” more recently it has been “crowdfunding.” This month it’s a form of crowdfunding taken to the extreme, the ice bucket challenge. Some have been so swept up in the hype that they have gone as far to say that the challenge is “rewriting the charity model.”

Oh boy.

The reality is that if you want to create social change you need to develop a sustainable financial model that aligns with your long-term goals. It’s not sexy, it’s not easy, and I’m probably one of the few people on this planet who thinks it’s fun. But there it is.

While many nonprofits are scrambling to figure out how to create their own ice bucket challenge, and some thought leaders are offering tips along the way, maybe we should all just take a step back.

Let’s be very clear. ALS’s close to $100 million windfall is not a revenue stream. It is a one-time infusion of money. Yes, ALS may try to replicate the ice bucket challenge on a regular basis, but the stars will never align in quite the same way, people will move on to the next shiny object, and the money will eventually fade.

Because this pile of money is not a revenue stream, ALS can’t and shouldn’t add long-term staffing or programming because the money won’t be there next year. At the same time, they probably can’t create an endowment because the donors’ intent was not for the money to sit in a bank account. Regranting the money is also tricky, again because donor intent was for it to go specifically to ALS. In all of this ALS will be under the microscope, because as Ken Berger of CharityNavigator cautioned, a year from now everyone will be asking where the money went.

One of the few paths that I see for ALS is to treat the money like capacity capital. This could be an opportunity to invest some of the windfall in building a stronger organization by investing in technology, infrastructure, and systems. And they could do the same for their affiliates. They could require capacity building plans and budgets and invest in those plans accordingly. They could, in essence, create a $100 million capacity capital investment fund for the ALS system.

But the point is that far from being a great thing that all nonprofits should strive to emulate, the ice bucket challenge creates a complex and potentially damaging problem.

So instead of spending board and staff time trying to dream up the next ice bucket challenge, please, please, please spend that time and those resources building your financial model, by creating a long-term financial strategy, raising capacity capital to build your revenue-generating function, developing a compelling strategic plan in which people will want to invest, and growing and educating your board.

These are the ingredients for a robust, sustainable financial model. Not a bucket of water, a video camera, and a social media stream.

Photo Credit: StoiKNA

 

Related Posts:

  • GEO Guest Post: From Uncomfortable Truths to Courageous Action
    GEO Guest Post: From Uncomfortable Truths to…
  • Nonprofit Scarcity Thinking Will Get You Nowhere
    Nonprofit Scarcity Thinking Will Get You Nowhere
  • The Way We Do Social Change is Broken, Let's Fix It
    The Way We Do Social Change is Broken, Let's Fix It
  • Will There Be a #MeToo Moment for the Nonprofit Sector?
    Will There Be a #MeToo Moment for the Nonprofit Sector?
FacebookTweetLinkedIn

Filed Under: Board of Directors, Capacity Building, Capacity Capital, Financing, Fundraising, Leadership, Nonprofits, Philanthropy, Social Change, Strategy Tagged With: capacity capital, CharityNavigator, crowdfunding, earned income, endowment, Fundraising, ice bucket challenge, Ken Berger, nonprofit, Philanthropy

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Rick Cohen says

    September 9, 2014 at 3:15 pm

    Well put, Nell. Too bad so many fundraisers seem so incredibly defensive about the shiny object strategy and aren’t thinking about revenue streams.

    Reply
  2. Nell Edgington says

    September 9, 2014 at 3:18 pm

    Yes, Rick, exactly. It’s part of the many dysfunctions of fundraising.

    Reply
  3. Janet Levine says

    September 17, 2014 at 4:54 pm

    You are–as usual–right on target. It is such a duh! that creating needed and sustainable revenue streams (and yes, I agree, sustainable is redundant when speaking of revenue streams, but the point seems never to be taken) is consistency and clarity of purpose. But doing it, over and over again, seems to be very much of a challenge–one that impedes real growth and success in our sector.

    Reply
  4. Nell Edgington says

    September 18, 2014 at 7:48 am

    Thanks Janet. I agree completely.

    Reply
  5. Karin Gerstenhaber says

    September 19, 2014 at 10:22 am

    Excellent article. I like you how succinctly you put it. Ten minutes (or 10 days) of social media fame doesn’t create long-term support, it’s more like the flavor of the day.

    Reply
  6. Nell Edgington says

    September 19, 2014 at 10:48 am

    Thanks Karin. Absolutely!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Consulting Services

If you want your nonprofit or foundation to do and be more, Social Velocity can help you get there

Ready to Learn More About Working with Social Velocity?

Apply for a Consultation
Reinventing Social Change Book

Download Chapter 1 of “Reinventing Social Change”

and keep up on webinars, training and events when you sign up for the Social Velocity e-list

Featured Blog Post Topics

  • Social Changemaker Interviews

  • Smart Strategic Planning

  • Effective Philanthropy

  • Networks for Social Change

  • The New Nonprofit Leader

  • A Groundbreaking Board

  • Reinventing the Nonprofit Sector

  • From Fundraising to Financing

Recent Posts

InReach Solutions Interview with Nell Edgington of Social Velocity

Talking About the Road to Nonprofit Abundance

red and white lifebuoy

How To Ask For (and Receive) The Help Your Nonprofit Needs

Join Me to Learn How to Start Attracting Abundance

Reinventing Social Change Book Available Now!

Order Your Copy of Reinventing Social Change

A little change image from Matt Artz

Move From Nonprofit Fundraising to Social Change Financing

Categories

  • Abundance
  • Advocacy
  • Board of Directors
  • Capacity Building
  • Capacity Capital
  • Financing
  • Fundraising
  • Individual Donors
  • Leadership
  • Marketing
  • Networks
  • Nonprofits
  • Philanthropy
  • Roadblocks
  • Social Change
  • Social Movements
  • Strategy

Footer

Reinventing Social Change Book

Download Chapter 1 of “Reinventing Social Change”

and keep up on webinars, training and events when you sign up for the Social Velocity e-list

InReach Solutions Interview with Nell Edgington of Social Velocity

Talking About the Road to Nonprofit Abundance

February 26, 2021

red and white lifebuoy

How To Ask For (and Receive) The Help Your Nonprofit Needs

February 10, 2021

Join Me to Learn How to Start Attracting Abundance

January 28, 2021

Reinventing Social Change Book Available Now!

Order Your Copy of Reinventing Social Change

January 21, 2021

A little change image from Matt Artz

Move From Nonprofit Fundraising to Social Change Financing

January 14, 2021

Recent Tweets

Tweets by nedgington
  • Consulting
  • Book
  • Clients
  • Speaking
  • Blog
  • About
  • Connect
  • Tools

© 2020 Social Velocity · Privacy Policy